Tobin Jewelers | Milwaukee Diamonds, Custom Jewelry & Repairs

Welcome to Tobin Jewelers

Over three generations, we have learned that each family’s jewelry collection highlights what is extraordinary and meaningful about the people who are wearing it. We help customers create brilliant combinations of style and personality by doing three things expertly: carefully selecting an outstanding inventory, educating our customers about how to make the best jewelry choices for them, and providing a lifetime of outstanding care for the jewelry after it has become part of our customers’ collections.

The foundation of our success has been relentlessly seeking out the best sources for diamonds, other stones, and settings. Whether they are deciding between stones, settings, or styles, we plan our inventory so that customers can make as many examinations and comparisons as they need to be fully confident in their purchase. Whichever options they are considering in our showroom, Tobin customers know that any choice will give them the finest quality craftsmanship.


At Tobin Jewelers, we hand-select hundreds of loose diamonds in Russia and Antwerp, Belgium each year. Visit one of our showrooms to learn about the 4 Cs and see diamonds side-by-side for yourself. 

Bridal Jewelry

We offer diamonds of exceptional beauty and workmanship, set into breathtaking engagement rings, wedding rings, and wedding bands from the world’s top designers.

Custom Design

With three generations of experience, Tobin sets the standard in Milwaukee custom jewelry. We invite you to learn more about the design process and visit our New Berlin or Mequon jewelry showrooms to find out how we can help you.

Guaranteed For Life

We provide the extra services that show customers we stand by our work years after purchase: free inspections, appraisals, re-appraisals, and a reputation-backed warranty that leaves out the surprises and fine print.